Mystery Farmers 2016 Edition

Very sly Mir! Very, very sly!

But we know who you are! "2!

 

I asked Fuzzles for help but he said I had to wait for the reset for more cake in just under 2 hours.

Good to see you Mir! We've missed you

I think I need to give poppy's Poppy a belly rub and see what hints I can get

A million carrots and lettuce? Wow! I know broke, Mir, meba and One-Two have talked about that but Sigh, alas, still confuzzled.

 

I am confused about a few of my choices now after reading all the post but here are my choices:

#1 Brookeham because she loves her cats and elephants in pink tutus
#2 Mir likes red pens and the challenge of the game plus the interactions in the forum
#3 Sweet_Cassiopeia not sure I think I remember the same story about how she made her farm name
#4 Davidb for the funny poem he wrote about the xxl capla trees

I going to have a sangria maybe that will help clear up my confusion.

 

#4 could be oldman49?
Hes often grumpy lol

 

I'm joining pnp
Still giggling over Aluntino being a goat and Mr Grumpy now being a Mrs
Great to see everyone

 

My new and revised list:

1) Brooke
2) If it's not Mir it has to be Meba - another Queen extraordinaire
3) 12sss12. So many have guessed one-two as a mystery farmer and so will I! She's #3!
4) If it's not Mrs Grumpy (), Jools or Mooboy, and I still think 4 is male; could it be habalala? Not usually grumpy but for the sake of the game...who knows??

 

We have so many grumpy persons in our forum ?

I am still in the forefront. And have not lost even after third round. That's nice.

Alright, out of consideration for having such beautiful name 'poppy' I will switch my choice to number 1. If we Vikings are not last, then we are first. No intermediate. So it will be number 1. I don't want you to get into trouble with 'beautifully named' poppy because of me.



P.S. Poppy, I am not making any serious guesses. If I do I will post a solemn post with just answers and without unnecessary comments.
I like this thread. You can blabber whatever you want.

 

I agree. Your brain is better at thinking than you.
Bhodho! No way, can't ever be him in any of those scenarios. No...

 

Mir! I'm sorry you couldn't play this time, but I'm glad you popped in to say hello Good guess, by the way.
Hi, tlcmom and cylentlea! Sangria you say? A girl after my own heart! It is a lot to try to sort through all the posts. It often leads to what Pnp and JJ mentioned: confuzzlement!
Oh, one-two, I know you were just being silly! Your posts have kept me laughing throughout the contest. I especially love your Viking Penguin. Pretty Poppy liked him, too.


But, I think this one is solved. All the mystery farmers have been matched to their set of answers at least once. Now, it's just a matter of putting them all together in their correct places.
Sglick- you have 3 correct
tlcmom, you have 1 correct
hatzeva you have 3 correct

Don't be fooled by distractions and silliness. The most obvious answer is the correct answer for at least one of the sets of clues.

 

Hmmm... either Poopy is scoring this wrong or I'm getting very confuzzled

Ok after reviewing the clues and the guesses so far as best I can, (which is probably very badly), here are the results of the Qatar jury

#4 certainly sounds like Mr G, but I believe him when he says he has better then play silly games. It could be me, but I'm sure I would have remembered answering the questions!, so going out out a limb here

#1 Brookeham - for all the reasons everyone stated
#2 Meba - coz she likes those red pens and axe throwing
#3 12SS - simply because it's not any of the others
#4 Kaydd - The Lady doth protest too much

 

1. Brookeham
2. Meba
3. 12ss12
4. Mr. Grumpy

 

Hmmm... you seem to be onto something there, try saying his name 3 times and see if he does indeed turn up

 

Oh boy you have all been busy since I last checked in here.
sglick - I knew you would very hard to fool. You know me so well....being my twisted sister and all. I was just poking fun when I said you caved under peer pressure.

hatzeva - Thanks so much for the compliment of having a "special, cheerful Brooke tone". Do I have a tone? I guess I do.

My guesses for the last 2
#3 Moraine - why? I don't know.....no one has mentioned her.....so maybe it could be? LOL
#4 Jools - why not? LOL

Super fun edition of mystery farmer game!
Thanks poppy!!!!

p.s. BC...you have to give reasons for your answers...or your guesses may be disqualified.

 

Jools, it wouldn't be the first time I'd gotten it all mixed up...but I think I got it right this time. The Qatar jury did quite well battling the confuzzlement. You got 3 correct! Hmm, Kaydd as #4? Actually, that's a good guess. Why did everyone automatically assume that our grump was a man? Ladies can be grumps, too! Oh, but not Kaydd. She's been one of my dearest neighbors for years, and I would never consider her a grump. In fact, she's quite lovely.
BlackCaviar, nice to see you! Just a quick question... do you need a tiger stall on your farm? Well, you've got one coming your way! You figured us all out! Congratulations!!

Sorry for distracting about Mr. Grumpy the whole time. I never actually said it wasn't him. We knew you'd guess Mr. Grumpy right away, but thought it'd be fun to make you question yourself. I guess he does have a little time for forum games...though I wonder if Mr. Grumpy only agreed to play because he enjoys contributing to mass confuzzlement.
(Said it 3 times, let's see if it's true... if not maybe would could try: Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetleju-- ah, no. I'd better not.)


Aww, Brooke, thanks! I couldn't have done it without you. (And I wouldn't have wanted to)

Give me a moment to consult with Poppy (the puppy) and I'll be back with the winners list.

 

After carefully reviewing who said what and trying to figure out the logic of a Maltese - that doesn't seem to be the right name for Poppy's Poppy. Isn't a Maltese a bird like a Falcon??? Or is it just a detective crime drama????

Anyways, I am absolutely certain about MF 1, 3, & 4's identity as Brookeham, 12sss12, & Mr. & Mrs. Grumpy AKA Jools AKA JoolsTwo.
I am also absolutely certain that #2 is NOT Mir, Meba or Broke.

The other possibilities are -- well I'm not gone to tell you. You can go back through the posts and write down every name that was mentioned as a possible MF regardless of the number. I know how Poppy's mind thinks. On the other hand, I have no clue how Poppy thinks.

So after all my research:

1. Brookeham
2. TLCmom
3. 12sss12
4. Mr_Grumpy

If this is not write then it is:

1. Brookeham
2. Kaydd
3. 12sss12
4. Mr_Grumpy

EDIT: I have a bone to pick with Poppy the Puppy about her Mommy's logic in saying who had how many correct each time.

Congratulations Blackcavier and everyone else who guessed correctly! and also those who are awful at guessing (like me) and just wanted to have fun.

EDIT 2: Brooke, I never take your seriously. I know we are always just trying to have fun.

 

Okay, Brooke. Reasons? I could say just because I said so. That worked for our parents, didn't it?

Actually I guessed based on sglick's answers. Just changed the one that I thought was not correct.


Thanks poppyseed! I will be happy to give a Tiger a nice home!

 

Oh please point out any mistakes before I write up the winners list! I think most of the problems occurred when people gave multiple answers for just one. I may have confused which answer they intended to go with.

 

I'm only teasing, because I am a sore loser.

Meba - We just don't use the word muck. We would say we are cleaning out a stall. We do use slang - a lot, but we don't really have one for cleaning. I am sure my fellow American will correct me on this and remind me of a ton of other slang words for cleaning that I can't think of right now.

 

I have heard the term mucking out used in horse barns but it is not common elsewhere. We usually just say we are cleaning.