List of rejected suggestions

I have seen a list of rejected suggestions in the German Forum.
Any chance to get this implemented here as well?
I think, this list would help players to see, what is has been already forwarded to the developers and what the outcome was.
e.g. I was wondering, why I am not getting any chicks since I applied to the mentoring system. In that listing I have seen, that the mentoring system has been stopped and no changes will be implemented nor will suggestions to it be forwarded.

Thank you

Auntie EDIT says: The listing in the German forum is actually pinned to the top as a first post in the player suggestion thread group

 

Great idea clonahmon!!! I too made a suggestion to implement elephant breeding....and am curious when/if it was forwarded to the developers. It also would be conveyed why a suggestion wasn't a good idea. These don't need to be lengthy explanations...just a sentence or 2.

 

Superb idea. It sure would be helpfull to know about any follow up -or not- on players suggestions.

 

I'm just curious, how often do these suggestions actually get implemented?

 

Would imagine never ...because not a lot has been changed from what I can see
People have asked for an Orchard...that's never happened

Played an Island game once ....you could go to peoples Islands and help them with chores ...little people moved ..was brilliant it was marginally better than farmerama... On the last day they speeded the game up so we finished all that we were working on ..which I thought was nice

They couldn't afford to get another server ...so it closed ...a few of us played from farmerama ...there are only two of us still playing here
farmerama should have bought that and added it to this game

We have a list of neighbours ..but we don't get enough gifts to give to all ...I HATE not being able to send to all on my list

 

Pretty sure the elephant breeding suggestion is in the "one day" box

I too would love to know those that got forwarded (doubt all suggestions do), and those that firmly got the "This will not be implemented at this stage" stamp on them. I know the English forum is tiny, so I wouldn't mind if other forums suggestions too were added to that list.

Or I could really brush of the dust on my language skills and start playing/reading in German Maybe more realstic

 

There is also a list of forwarded and implemented/partly implemented suggestions in the German Forum in the suggestion group (besides the official bugfix/improvement threads)

 

I would really like if we also had that kind of list here in EN forum!

 

It would be nice to know why a suggestion is rejected. If you knew you might be able to revise it so that it is "workable" for BP.

 

I agree here 10000000 percent.....lol

 

An example of something being implemented is the Product Quest for hammocks, "Just Hanging Out". At level 10, the 'all harvest helpers' rewards are now vouchers, instead of the instant all harvest helpers on other earlier Product Quests. Yahoo !!

 

Elephant breeding is coming now YEAH!!!! SURPRISE

 

Nice find clonahmon! Is it possible to post a link to these threads in this one? If not here maybe under Game Related Chit Chat?
I am sure many if not all of our suggestions have been voiced on the German Forum. It would be nice to know why we can not gift to each of our neighbors, every day... ETC...
I do not know how to get to another Forum without a link. Maybe just a link to the Front page of the German Forum would be allowed. From your description of the locations even I could find them(I think).

 

We don't ever seem to know of things like this in this forum .. ..we seem to be forgotten.... without people searching other forums ...we wouldn't know anything
How and where do other forums get this information because they seem to be very well informed?

 

More active forums => more mods => more time to go the extra mile.
But I have to say we do have a great forum, with players that trawls all the other forums and gives us the the best of the others. Not sure the other forums are as blessed with that as we are.

I really hope this suggestion is taken further.

 

Yes we do have a great forum Moraine you are right ...it couldn't get any better .... 12ss12 very kindly gives her time to give us all the information to play the events A very BIG Thank you 12ss12

Dont think I am going to be able to finish this event ... Don't know why ...just couldn't seem to get into this event..Maybe event over load with grow and throw events that are boring
Have finished all the givers ..But somehow don't think i will be able to get the cloud Row to put them on... have 3 squares to complete in China

This is suppose to be a FREE game yet we aren't given enough chances to make BBS the Movies is only giving ONE movie to watch ...we used to have 4 each day and that could still be done by showing that one movie again 3 more times ...without the machinery events of this kind are not easy

SO I am now going to look for a new game to play..because i dont think this will get any better ...Since being taken over this game has changed in many ways...barn clearing ??? back to back events I don't like that ...have worked hard for years to get these things

 

http://de.bigpoint.com/farmerama/board/index.php

 

Thank you clonahmon. It does gives a little insight.